Rejections

One of my JavaScript items is rejected, and the reason given is “These types of menus are quite common – I suggest creating something a little more unique.”. But from my experience, the item I created it not a common menu at all, so I want to fire a review and tell the reviewers why it is unique.

So where or what should I do ?

may be your experience is limited.

Share the menus with us if you can

You can reply to the reviewers email with any questions you have regarding the rejection and we can forward it along, but getting feedback from fellow authors is a great idea

Thanks Omarabid, and CreatingDrew:

Basically the menu/site map looks like this http://www.the-di-lab.com/jnavi-demo/jNavi-demo-1.html.
It is dynamically drew from a XML data source. I resubmitted it again with more clarifications, see if it gets through. Let me know if you guys think it is “Common menu”.

“We will be builing more demos. ” =\

Personally though I consider the javascript dropdown menu market to be a solved problem.

This dropdown menu hasn’t shown me anything that makes me go wow.

If anything its of fixed height and width and wouldn’t fit into a website without some wrangling.

“We will be builing more demos. ” =\

Personally though I consider the javascript dropdown menu market to be a solved problem.

This dropdown menu hasn’t shown me anything that makes me go wow.

If anything its of fixed height and width and wouldn’t fit into a website without some wrangling.

Well, in my case, I actually called it multi-purpose navigation.

One way of using it will be a dynamic site map, Image you have a site map page, will it be nice to build a site map in a navigational way?

P.S: its width and height can be changed.

I don’t think it’s that common. I’m not sure about the site map idea as one of the main goals behind a site map is that it’s static and helps the SEO of a website, but it could be useful for searching through large lists/databases, where other forms of navigation are less user friendly.
There’s a good example of this on AMD ’s website

I don’t think it’s that common. I’m not sure about the site map idea as one of the main goals behind a site map is that it’s static and helps the SEO of a website, but it could be useful for searching through large lists/databases, where other forms of navigation are less user friendly.
There’s a good example of this on AMD ’s website

Thanks theninja:

Basically you got my idea, and yeah, I was building something like the sample you given AMD ’s website.

It is made to make navigation of the large site easier, and more user friendly.

You can always have other SEO version of site map along with mine.