Hi, My first file on codecanyon was rejected. You can see the item preview at http://www.pigrecolab.com/mylogin
I think the reviewer is right…
It lacks enough complexity for it to be useful. As a stand alone ‘app’ you wouldn’t even pay $1 for that. If you look at some of the other items priced $5 it provides much more functionality.
Your best bet is to add to this with more features. It might stand a chance of selling.