Posts by kailoon

Just purchase it

Good luck to your sales

Personally I think if the author has checked the theme as being compatible with 2.7 (from the drop-down box), then the theme should support threaded comments.

The theme should also be compatible with older versions, which you can do by adding the following to functions.php:

<?php add_filter( 'comments_template', 'legacy_comments' );
function legacy_comments( $file ) {
    if ( !function_exists('wp_list_comments') )
        $file = TEMPLATEPATH . '/comments.legacy.php';
    return $file;
}
?>

Older versions of WordPress will then use comments.legacy.php for comments, while 2.7+ can use comments.php ( Read More )

Or perhaps we could have a drop-down Yes/No box for threaded/paged comment support?

I think it is a good idea, but for the moment. Author will need to mention in the theme description. I found that people will assume that your theme is supporting threaded/page comment if it is compatible with 2.7.

Can use mine?

http://themeforest.net/item/myproperty-listing/24519

I think it is a bit complicated but the filter function maybe an interesting point for jQuery beginner

Malaysia > KL . Peace ya!

Oh, I found someone is from Malaysia too Hello!

Do you think Nested and Paged Comments are compulsory for a WordPress theme which compatible to 2.7?

Definitely, WordPress is your best option

increase of 1 to 10 bucks

This item doesn’t meet our criteria = modify & reupload

This item need improvements or fixed = it’s close

Actually, Just the two above. And the first one is actually refer to “Your design was rejected due to aesthetic reasons” and it is better to start over. But if the author think that he can still improve from there. He still can do it.

Maybe I didn’t explain it well… Personal taste, doesn’t mean it have to follow my style… For sure the design will be judged as what you mentioned too.

Sorry if this cause even more confusion…

When they pay you by the hour to judge whether the file should be approved or not there is not much time writing why the design isn’t good. Instead I think there should be a pre-written list with reasons for rejection. For example: “Your design was rejected due to aesthetic reasons” or “Your design was rejected due to IE6 incompatibility” and so on.

Ya, normally, I will use this reason to reject an item which is not ready for TF. I found that it is hard to tell the author that your design is not good or bad or ugly. I don’t know others but me, myself, I find it hard to write that. So, when you received rejection with reason stated “Your design was rejected due to aesthetic reasons”. Then, it is actually not any padding or margin issue. It is better you start another one.

I am trying to be nice to every author that got rejected. I understand my English isn’t good enough. I apologize here…

If a file need improvements, I will stated the reason and some tips if possible. I can’t give every single direction or clue. I hope you understand…

When you received “This item doesn’t meet our criteria” This mean the file is totally rejected. However, you can still modify it and re-upload.

When you received ” This item need improvements or fixed”. This mean the file is close to be approved after some improvements. Then, reviewer will point out some errors, tips or suggestions.

We never put our personal taste when doing review. For example, when I review a file that having the design that I don’t like, I will just review the functions, usabilities, codes etc. For sure I will see from the overall. Then, I will ask another reviewer, for now is Jeff, to review it and note down my comments. Then only we decide.

But, for PSD template. This may have need some personal taste. Because it is simply a layout design. Agree?

After I read many negative post about reviewers. I feel abit upset… Anyway, I just want to explain what I think and What I am doing. I hope I am doing the right thing. Any suggestions are welcome.

Thank you!